the american family association published a list of 10 arguments against same-sex marriage in 2008. Ostensibly a summary of james dobsons marriage under fire, the arguments made a very loose case against same-sex marriage based almost entirely on slippery slopes and out-of-context quotations from the bible. If youve never seen this list before, your first reaction may be anger. arguments against same-sex marriage centres typically on what opponents deem as devaluation of marriage as institution that could hard heterosexual relationships and their families. However, if there is anything that harms marriage, it is bad marriages in which couples disregard their responsibilities and their commitments toward their. thirteen bad arguments for same-sex marriage why the rhetoric doesnt stand up under scrutiny. cons of same-sex marriage (arguments against) same-sex marriage undermines the institution of marriage that has traditionally been defined as being between a man and a woman. One of the cons of gay marriage cited by people is that m arriage is for procreation (having children) and shouldnt be extended to same-sex couples since they are not. The top arguments for and against same-sex marriage at the supreme court. 04292015 0417 pm et updated feb 02, 2016 okay what is the supreme court thinking about marriage? They just heard oral argument from gay couples, from the states that want to preserve their bans, and from the u. ten arguments from social science against same-sex marriage. July 6, 2004 family research council bodytext a large and growing body of scientific evidence indicates that the intact, married family is best for children. In particular, the work of scholars david popenoe, linda waite, maggie gallagher, sara mclanahan, david blankenhorn, paul. Accordingly, more and more people are starting to acknowledge the flawed nature of all arguments which oppose the legalization of same-sex marriage. This article discusses 10 of the most common positions presented by opponents of marriage equality and outlines why each deserves a failing grade. Marriage is not just a piece of paper or pile of benefits, its a unique promise one makes to another in the presence of a community. Civil unions weaken the idea of marriage and are bad policy for the future of same-sex marriage. same-sex couples didnt receive the same help when they werent able to marry. Much of what gay partners should have been able to do for each other had to be shouldered by the community at large, unnecessarily draining resources. By solidifying relationships, gay marriage will help stabilize communities overall.